Both stockholder and stakeholder theories are normative theories of corporate social responsibility that outline the ethical responsibilities of a corporation. Stakeholder theory and the corporate objective revisited. The stakeholder perspective is an alternative way of understanding how companies and people create value and trade with each other. The debate between shareholder theory and stakeholder theory is framed by liberal and libertarian justifications that hinge primarily on whether and to what extent one should have exogenous or endogenous safeguards on corporate behavior. The corporation belongs to stockholders and in their interest must be run. The 1930 berledodd debate dealt with shareholder primacy versus the stakeholder approach. Stakeholder theory represents a continuum of assumptions as shown in figure 2. A utilitarian perspective on the csr debate stakeholder theory vs. Larson july 14, 20 stewardship theory history and overview stewardship theory is a relatively new concept karns, 2011 and assumes that the manager is a steward of the business with behaviors and objectives consistent with those of the owners.
Why stakeholder and stockholder theories are not necessarily contradictory. A powerpoint presentation that discusses the difference between shareholder and stakeholder theory in the context of the economics of strategy. This belief helped shape his shareholder theory of capitalism. Youll notice right off that freemans stakeholder theory replaces the. Shareholder theory economist milton friedman, whose work shaped much of 20thcentury corporate america, was a believer in the freemarket system and no government intervention.
Stakeholder theory vs shareholder theory and its impact on business. The idea of the shareholder theory is that managers primarily have a duty to maximize shareholders interests in the way that is still permitted by law or social values. So, shareholder theory is a form of ethical egoism. A conservative view on csr suggests that the only purpose of a business organization is to generate profits and promote the interests of its owners or. Economist milton friedman introduced this idea in the 1960s, which states a corporation is primarily responsible to its shareholders. At length, like the shareholder primacy theory, the stakeholder theory fails to balance the interests held by a person who play double role in corporations either.
But, best promotes ones own self interest is just what maximizes their own profits means in business terminology. The theory that youve just read about is significantly different from the stockholder theory that we saw from friedman. Shareholder vs stakeholder theory ac 1204 introduction the cadbury committee 1992 defined corporate governance as the system by which companies are directed and controlled. Shareholder value a theory that changed the course of. Stakeholder theory and the corporate objective revisited organization science 153, pp. Shareholder theory is the view that the only duty of a corporation is to maximize the profits accruing to its shareholders. Second, we will clarify the meaning attributed to the stakeholder value and the method by which it was measured. Shareholders in corporate governance 2 part i shareholders, shareholder value, and stakeholders 1. The stakeholder theory suggests there are differences between individual groups within an organization, such as the employees, investors, and suppliers. In order to develop a theory of the firm, the shareholder approach returns to the estalished b. A fiduciary argument against stakeholder theory business.
The second part deals specifically with the issue of the principalagent problem in a stakeholder context. It addresses morals and values in managing an organization, such as those related to corporate social responsibility, market economy, and social contract theory. Shareholder val ue a theory that changed the course of history for the better or the worse. Springer nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. The debate between shareholder theory and stakeholder theory is framed by liberal and libertarian justifications that hinge primarily on whether and to what extent one should have exogenous or. Though this debate was not specifically extended to the concept of corporate governance at that time, with the advancement of law, governments, academicians and advocates now question the viability of various theories for the purpose of corporate governance.
This, in agreement with keay, i believe is one the major reasons due to which the debate. An overview when it comes to investing in a corporation, there are shareholders and stakeholders. Agency theory primarily focuses on the interest of the shareholder s, while principal theory includes the entire range of stakeholders. Stakeholders is a group that is broader than shareholders. Yes, sometimes the interests are in conflict, but over time they must be shaped in the same direction. The strategic approach to stakeholder theory views stakeholders instrumentally. Two competing theories of corporate social responsibility 1. Agency theory and stakeholder theory compared business.
Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. A guide for the perplexed, business ethics quarterly 8, no. Stockholder theory and stakeholder theory map out these two paths, allowing each business to decide which ethical path it will choose to take. One which states that businesses do have social responsibilities. The stakeholder principle, corporate governance, and. An identification of the value limits of this partnership will subsequently be studied. Essay on friedman vs freeman 827 words 4 pages stakeholder theory of management, two different views about the purpose and aims of a business. The main challenger is stakeholder theory, which argues that the corporation exists to benefit not just investors but all its major constituenciesemployees, customers, suppliers, the local community, and the federal government, as well as shareholders. Milton friedmans shareholder theory of management says that the purpose of a business is to make money for the owner or the stockholders of the business. Enron case is a remarkable example to show the failure of shareholder theory in pursuing shareholder wealth maximization not paying attention to stakeholder s interests.
Theories of corporate social responsibility profolus. Im sure that you remember friedmans thesis, but here it is as a reminder. Conflicts between shareholder theory and stakeholder. This paper will outline what each of these theories is, and underscore some of the issues in this debate. Goodpaster 1991 builds on the work of freeman 1984 and divides stakeholder theory into three approaches of strategic, multifiduciary, and a synthesis. The law as constraint and potential enabler of stakeholder concerns april 20, 2018. Larsons m3a1 stewardship theory, stakeholder theory, and. Stakeholder theory is a view of capitalism that stresses the interconnected relationships between a business and its customers, suppliers, employees, investors, communities and others who have a stake in the organization. While they have similarsounding names, their investment in a company.
The economic model of corporate social responsibility or the shareholder theory of corporate governance. Stakeholder theory shareholder theory claims corporation managers have a duty to maximize shareholder returns. Depicted on the right end of the continuum, normative stakeholder theory stands in antithesis to shareholder value theory. The stakeholder theory is a theory of organizational management and business ethics that accounts for multiple constituencies impacted by business entities like employees, suppliers, local communities, creditors, and others. Agency theory argues that shareholder interests require protection by separation of incumbency of ro. Results of an empirical test fail to support agency theory and provide some support for stewardship theory. Both stockholder and stakeholder theories are normative theories of corporate social responsibility that outline the ethical responsibilities of. Lets take a look at freemans thesis, and see just how different they are. Essec business school is a center of academic excellence underpinned by its facultys research. If stakeholder interests are being considered only as a means to the end of profitability, then managers are using stakeholders to effect the results dictated by the shareholder theory. Stakeholder theory is introduced by edward freeman in 1988. According to the stakeholder theory, managers are agents of stakeholders who must ensure that the ethical rights of stakeholders are not violated and their legitimate interests are balanced while making decisions. Using a utilitarianism framework, this paper will be explaining the important factors in favor of the stakeholder theory, as well as the shortcomings in the shareholder theory, and that organizations should base their csr activities on stakeholder.
Keay, in dealing with the concept of shareholder versus stakeholder approach, points out that every author and institution has assigned andor interpreted andor assumed different meaning of shareholder primacy. The shareholder and stakeholder theories of corporate purpose. Stakeholder theory in business, there is a conflict of ideas between the competing ideas of shareholder theory and stakeholder theory. Shareholder theory shareholder theory is the idea that businesses work for the shareholders. Customers tend to shy away from companies that are negligent towards other stakeholders and firms may have to cope with massive revenue loss thus affecting shareholder s wealth. Recall that ethical egoism is the view which states that the morally right action is the one that best promotes ones own selfinterest. Shareholder theory has been criticized by proponents of stakeholder theory, who believe the friedman doctrine is inconsistent with the idea of corporate social responsibility to stakeholders. Stakeholder theory as an ethical approach to effective management.
Stakeholder theory free download as powerpoint presentation. A utilitarian perspective on the csr debate stakeholder. It presents a view of the corporation balancing a community of interests for the benefit of all. The theory argues that a firm should create value for all stakeholders, not just shareholders. Freeman, harrison and zyglidopoulos discuss the foundation concepts and implementation of stakeholder management as well as the advantages this approach provides to firms and their managers. Shareholder theory vs stakeholder theory prolific essays. Numerous theories have been proposed on corporate governance best practice, none more popular than the shareholder and stakeholder theories. Agency theory fails to recognize that neglecting other stakeholder s results to ultimate neglect of shareholder s need to maximize profits. In doing so, instrumental stakeholder theory becomes a subset of shareholder value theory. Stewardship theory argues shareholder interests are maximised by shared incumbency of these ro.